What is the history of Everton FC?
Founded in 1878 (Liverpool was founded after a dispute at Everton in 1892 — a fact Toffees fans love mentioning). They've won 9 league titles, putting them 4th on the all-time English honors list. The 1980s under Howard Kendall were a golden era — two league titles and a Cup Winners' Cup. The modern era has been about survival in the Premier League — Everton are one of only six clubs to have spent every Premier League season in the top flight, but recent seasons have been spent fighting relegation. New American owners The Friedkin Group bought the club in 2024 and the team moved into the brand new Hill Dickinson Stadium on the Liverpool waterfront in 2025.
What is it like to support Everton FC?
Loyal, gritty, slowly turning the corner. David Moyes is back in his second spell as manager and steadying the ship. The football is pragmatic — they grind out results rather than play beautiful soccer. The new stadium is genuinely stunning and represents the biggest moment in the club's modern history. The vibe right now is cautiously optimistic for the first time in a decade.
What is Everton FC fan culture like?
Everton's matchday is one of the most authentic experiences in English football. The fanbase is generationally local — most Evertonians' parents and grandparents were Evertonians. The fierce pride about being "the people's club" of Liverpool (vs Liverpool FC's global reach) defines the identity. "Z-Cars" before kickoff and "Spirit of the Blues" are iconic anthems. The Goodison Park atmosphere on a derby day was legendary; the new stadium will need time to develop its own. American fanbase is smaller than Liverpool's but tight-knit and proud of choosing the harder path.
Why should an American support Everton FC?
- +Pure, generational, locally-rooted football identity
- +Brand new stadium for 2025-26 — exciting era beginning
- +Smaller global fanbase = you're not bandwagoning anything
- +Merseyside Derby is one of the most fierce fixtures in the league
- +American owners (Friedkin Group) investing for the long term
Reasons not to support Everton FC
- −Recent seasons have been relegation battles, not European chases
- −Liverpool fans will dominate the city's global narrative for the foreseeable future
- −Pragmatic football — not the prettiest watch most weeks
Which American sports team is Everton FC most like?
Closest US sports comp: Pittsburgh Pirates or Cleveland Guardians — proud history, modest modern era, deeply local identity. Or the LA Clippers in the Lakers' shadow.
Who are Everton FC's most famous players?
Who are Everton FC's biggest rivals?
Not sure Everton FC is your team?
Our 60-second quiz matches Americans to the Premier League team that fits their personality, taste, and sports background.
Take the quizFrequently asked questions
Why are Everton called The Toffees?
From a sweet shop near Goodison Park called "Old Mother Noblett's Toffee Shop" — fans started bringing toffees to games in the early 1900s.
Why did Everton leave Goodison Park?
Goodison was a beloved historic ground but couldn't generate modern matchday revenue. The new Hill Dickinson Stadium on the waterfront opened in 2025.
Who came first — Everton or Liverpool?
Everton, by 14 years (1878 vs 1892). Liverpool was founded after a rent dispute at Everton's then-ground, Anfield. Toffees fans will not let you forget this.